Ethinvest's Trevor Thomas on why investors should think twice about a supposed coal and gas revival
Anyone attending the AFR's recent Energy and Climate Summit could be forgiven for thinking that investment in coal and gas is going full steam. But managed decline should not be mistaken for growth, Ethinvest's Trevor Thomas writes in The Energy.
From NSW and Queensland to the Federal Government, recent fossil fuel project announcements could be interpreted as a signal that coal and gas companies are worth reconsidering. But investors should be very careful about allocating capital to the sector.
First, look closely at what is actually being proposed. In NSW, Minister Penny Sharpe herself says the new gas plants will run only occasionally as backup when wind, sun and storage fall short. That is a real role, but it is insurance capacity designed to sit idle most of the year. It is not the long-life, high-volume supply business that new basins and pipelines need to pay for themselves.
Second, look at what our most important international customers are doing. South Korea, Australia's third-largest thermal coal market, just unveiled a 1,000 trillion won (that's an incredible AU$1.1 trillion) industrial transformation plan running to 2035. It targets 100GW of renewables by 2030, electric and hydrogen vehicles making up more than 70 per cent of new car sales by 2035, and the world's first mass production of hydrogen-reduced steel. Seoul has already committed to closing all 62 of its coal plants by 2040. This is not a country planning to buy more of our fossil fuels. Rather, it is planning to cut fossil fuels and to build new, decarbonised industries for its economic future.
For investors, the risk is timing. A gas field or coal mine approved today on the back of a 2026 shortage, or a price spike caused by conflict in the Middle East, needs buyers for decades, and that is far from assured.
The biggest risk, though, is the opportunity we could miss. Korea's new energy plan could be an Australian shopping list: green iron, critical minerals, renewable hydrogen, batteries, solar and grid equipment. We have the ore, sun, wind and trade relationships to partner with Korea and supply much of it. Every dollar of policy attention and investment spent defending fossil fuel expansion is a dollar not spent winning that business. Japan, Korea and China will buy it from someone.
Australia should be looking forward, not backwards. We are unusually well placed to supply a changing world with renewable energy, batteries, critical minerals, green metals and, increasingly, clean fuels.
Read Trevor's full op-ed in The Energy.







