Supreme Court rules that anti-coal protest on Newcastle Harbour can continue
An anti-coal climate protest on Newcastle Harbour went ahead in November after the NSW Supreme Court rejected an application by NSW Police to stop it. Organisers Rising Tide were supported in the urgent case by legal organisation Climate Defenders.
More than 1,000 people took part in Rising Tide's Paddle for the Planet, the biggest on-water flotilla yet at the world's largest coal port. Held during the COP31 climate negotiations, the protest called for an end to coal and gas extraction and exports to ensure a liveable climate. Roughly 600 participants in single and double kayaks, on surfboards, and in sailboats and motorboats formed a line across the harbour and floated a banner reading "COAL EXPORTS = CLIMATE CHAOS".
NSW Police had asked the court to prohibit the demonstration, arguing that a flotilla of that size in open water posed serious risks of collision, capsizing and drowning. In his decision, Justice Edward Muston acknowledged the legitimate concerns raised by police but concluded that they did not outweigh the importance of allowing peaceful political assembly. No major injuries or incidents occurred, and police allowed the event to proceed unimpeded.
"The public interests in the facilitations of political expression through assembly outweighs the legitimate concerns which have been expressed by the commissioner," Justice Muston said.
The ruling comes amid a wider dispute over Rising Tide's demonstrations in Newcastle, where the city council recently voted to oppose the group using community land for future protests. For activists, the harbour demonstration was a chance to focus international attention on Australia's coal exports as global leaders gathered for COP31, the United Nations climate conference.
"This case is important for protest rights, as our client tries to have a short and safe protest on waters that carry Australian coal out of the country to be burnt offshore contributing to climate change and causing more intense extreme weather events," said Dr Josh Pallas, Legal Director at Climate Defenders.
Interested in supporting the effort? Donate to Climate Defenders to help protect the right to protest, take part in future Rising Tide events, or donate to Rising Tide to help them organise.








